Media logo
Elections

New election rules will feature media regulation, Georgian Dream MP says

New election rules will feature media regulation, Georgian Dream MP says
MP Irakli Kobakhidze, Speaker Archil Talakvadze, and Chair of the Central Election Commission Tamar Zvhania during the 5 August Working Group meeting (Retrieved from Talakvadze’s official FB page)

To the chagrin of critics, the ruling party has recently announced that their proposed package of electoral reforms include regulations on campaign finance rules and political ads in media. 

On Monday, 5 August, Georgian Dream member and parliamentary speaker Archil Talakvadze presented a set of several general proposals to regulate the elections.

The full details of the amendment are not yet available to the public nor to all the watchdog organisations involved in the Special Working Group on Electoral Legislation Reform organised by the Georgian Parliament.

However, several proposals from the draft law concerning the regulation of media have been released.

After the meeting within the Working Group, Irakli Kobakhidze, Georgian Dream’s Executive Secretary, confirmed to journalists that they want to regulate ‘hate speech and xenophobia’ during the election campaign.

Georgian Dream leaders cited ‘recommendations from the OSCE’ as a confirmation that Georgia needed to tackle the problem.

Among their 27 recommendations after the autumn 2018 presidential elections released in February, the Office for Democratic Institutions and Human Rights (ODIHR) of the OSCE noted that ‘contrary to international good practice, comprehensive legislation on hate speech’ was absent in Georgia.

‘Relevant authorities should be in a position to review potential cases of hate speech and where appropriate, apply sanctions in a timely manner’, the ODIHR report read.

Levan Natroshvili, the program manager of the advocacy group Transparency International — Georgia, told OC Media that while Georgian Dream have not yet come up with a definition of ‘hate speech’ there is nevertheless, ‘a risk of defining it too broadly, triggering a serious problem for freedom of expression’.

According to Natroshvili, hate speech is already regulated in Georgia ‘[according to] the broader American standards’ and that if need be, the media can practice ‘the mechanism of self-regulation’.

Among other ‘problematic’ initiatives, Natroshvili says, the ruling party also plan to oblige the media publicise the prices they charge for airing or publishing political ads before the start of a given election campaign — something they ‘won’t be able to alter later’.

There would also be a limit on the types of political advertising allowed on air, with a maximum of 25% of the air-time given to political advertisements allocated to attack ads.

Media organisations would be ‘obliged’ to police the content of political advertising, Natroshvili said. If they air anything that is ruled to be hate speech, if they exceed attack ad limits, or if in any other way they are found to be ‘in violation of the law’ they would be fined ‘double the price of the ad’.

‘It is unclear on what basis the ruling party decided that 25% negative ads is acceptable but 26% should be a violation’, Tamar Chikhladze, a journalist and anchor at the independent TV channel Pirveli, told OC Media. ‘However they rationalise it, it will still be a limitation placed on critical expression’.

‘[It] looks like the government that had actively used negative ads reminding [the public] about “nine years of bloody rule” [under the United National Movement] are now wary some could use similar reminders against them after [the violent police actions on] the night of 20–21 June’, Chikhladze said.

[Read more on OC Media: 5 violations by police during the Tbilisi clash]

The package and preliminary reactions

Talakvadze confirmed on Monday that they still intend to axe the minimum threshold (currently 3% of the total vote) for parties to enter parliament and replace the mixed electoral system with a fully proportional one for the 2020 elections — something they had promised in June.

Georgian Dream also offered to revise regulations on election campaign financing and promised ‘better’ state financing to smaller parties, including any party that would enter the parliament.

Talakvadze also said they want to ban political parties from transferring free media airtime allocated for them to another party.

Members of Georgian Dream had been complaining in recent months about smaller ‘satellite’ or ‘one-man’ parties within the opposition Power in Unity coalition yielding resources allocated to them to the formerly ruling United National Movement (UNM).

Additionally, the ruling party said they want to staff Electoral Commissions at all levels with 13 members, of which seven would be from political parties with ‘the majority from the opposition groups’. Who the other six members would be has not yet been announced.

In their February report, the ODIHR called for ‘more balanced’ political representation’ in Electoral Commissions — the bodies which administer elections throughout Georgia — and for ensuring that ‘state-funded resources for contestants are not used for the benefit of other candidates’.

Members of Parliament from the UNM and European Georgia confirmed their support for moving to the fully proportional system but indicated they were critical of other proposals made by Georgian Dream.

Tina Bokuchava, an MP from the UNM, told media on 5 August that her party found the proposals for ‘regulating airtime in media’ and a ban on election blocks ‘problematic’.

The UNM has been critical of the ban on election blocs that Georgian Dream had attached to their offer to replace the mixed majoritarian system of elections.

Otar Kakhidze, an MP from European Georgia, told media before the Working Group session on 5 August that they also wanted the ruling party to address forms of voter pressure and intimidation.

According to Kakhidze, during the last elections, the government tried to pressure voters by removing critics of the government from social assistance programs, tracking voters outside the polling stations, and instructing voters to show them a photograph of their ballot choice after exiting the polling station.

Related Articles

Illustration: Tamar Shvelidze/OC Media.
2024 Georgian Parliamentary Elections

Who’s who in Georgia’s parliamentary elections?

Avatar

Georgians will go to the polls on 26 October in crucial parliamentary elections. Unlike in previous years, this election will be held under a fully proportional system. This means parties will be allocated a percentage of parliament’s 150 seats based entirely on the percentage of votes they receive nationwide, doing away with elections for individual MPs in single-seat constituencies. However, despite calls from many smaller parties, and despite previously promising the opposite, the ruling

Ramzan Kadyrov with his family at the polling station. Screengrab from Telegram.
Chechnya

Little change after regional elections across North Caucasus

L

The United Russia party of President Vladimir Putin has won parliamentary majorities in two North Caucasus republics following elections which saw all current regional MPs keep their seats.  Voting began on 6 September for local elections throughout Russia, including in several parts of the North Caucasus.  These included the election of MPs to the parliaments of Kabarda-Balkaria and Karachay-Cherkessia. Separately, the heads of Kabarda-Balkaria and Ingushetia were elected by the local

Members of parliament present during the vote. Screengrab: Georgian Parliament/YouTube.
Democracy

Georgian Dream ‘fraudulently’ overturned electoral code veto

Avatar

The ruling Georgian Dream party appears to have fraudulently overturned a presidential veto on controversial amendments to Georgia’s electoral code, by falsely claiming that more MPs had voted than were present in the parliamentary session. The veto was overturned and amendments to Georgia’s electoral code were adopted in an extraordinary session of parliament held on 3 July, with the parliament reporting 78 votes in favour and 14 against. However, opposition Girchi MP Aleksandre Rakviashvil

Giorgi Khakhubia, the Georgian Dream candidate for Poti, Senaki, and Khobi, addresses supporters. Photo: Giorgi Khakhubia/Facebook.
Democracy

Georgian Dream triumphs in by-election after running practically unopposed

Avatar

The ruling Georgian Dream Party have won a by-election in the Poti, Senaki, and Khobi constituency after all but one minor opposition party failed to field candidates. According to preliminary results, Georgian Dream’s Giorgi Khakhubia won 95% of the vote in Saturday’s parliamentary by-election. The only other candidate was from Free Georgia, a minor opposition party headed by former MP Kakha Kukava. The election was called after the incumbent, Georgian Dream MP Irakli Khakhubia, passed away

Most Popular

Editor‘s Picks