Media logo
OC Insider

What is the value of a genocidal tyrant recognising the genocide of my people?

Don’t just read the news, help create it.

For just $5 a month, you can fund reporting that gives you in-depth insight into the Caucasus.

JOIN TODAY

A day after the Armenian Genocide Remembrance Day in April, I found myself at the Armenian Genocide memorial in Yerevan.

Despite it being the day after,  there was still a flow of people going up and down the hill where the memorial is located. Many came carrying flowers and taking a quiet moment to reflect on one of the greatest, if not the greatest, tragedies in Armenian history.

On display in the park adjacent to the memorial were the flags of countries that officially recognise the Armenian Genocide. I paused for a moment, looking at the short rows of flags — just over 30 — taking in, visually, how limited that number still is.

Years ago, as a teenager, with little understanding of international politics, I was deeply disappointed to learn that Israel, of all coutries, did not recognise the Armenian Genocide. As a nation who had endured a similar atrocity, I naively believed they could truly relate to our pain and acknowledge it with solidarity.

Years later, following all the failed attempts, some form of recognition has eventually come, but it has not brought any joy to my heart.

Earlier this week Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu appeared to recognise the Armenian Genocide while speaking on a podcast.

This casual format, which appeared to emerge spontaneously, was accompanied with disinformation that the Israeli Parliament had already passed a resolution recognising the genocide. On top of that, it came in an inappropriate venue — during an interview with the controversial US podcaster Patrick Bet-David, known for spreading conspiracy theories and giving a platform to Holocaust deniers.

Putting the formalities aside, I can’t ignore the elephant in the room.

Recognising a tragedy of such scale should mean taking a principled stance against genocide ANYWHERE, ANYTIME, AGAINST ANYONE. It should signal a commitment to preventing similar atrocities in the future. But if Netanyahu’s government is currently orchestrating a genocide in Gaza, what moral value does his recognition hold?

Moreover, the apparent recognition came after Israel sold weapons to Azerbaijan, the very weapons which were used against my people, playing a crucial role in the defeat of Armenians in the second Nagorno-Karabakh War in 2020 and an eventual ethnic cleansing of the region a few years later.

The tragedy Netanyahu claims to acknowledge includes the suffering of our ancestors, including of my great-grandparents who survived the genocide. And yet, their memory is used as a pawn in a political game that betrays everything that remembrance and recognition should stand for.

Related Articles

OC Insider

Tucker Carlson brings the ‘war on Christianity’ to the Caucasus

There is so much wrong with Tucker Carlson’s recent episode on Armenia — featuring Narek Kareptyan, the nephew of jailed Russian-Armenian tycoon Samvel Karapetyan and his amoral, opportunistic lawyer Robert Amsterdam — that it is hard to know where to begin. I think part of the reason I’m writing this newsletter is to put my thoughts on paper about the literal torrent of misinformation and false narratives contained in the episode (and to spare my coworkers, who are probably tired of hearing me

OC Insider

Ivanishvili’s ‘Georgian Dream’ of a populist right-wing Europe

When the European Council presented their latest enlargement report on Tuesday, no one was surprised by what was said about Georgia. EU enlargement chief Marta Kos called it ‘the worst enlargement report for any candidate country ever’. The response from the Speaker of the Georgian Parliament, Shalva Papuashvili, was also fairly typical. He accused the Brussels deep state/global war party of orchestrating a coup attempt, of financing radicalism, of blackmail — all par for the course. He also a

OC Insider

Five years of loneliness

It must be nice to come home when you live in another city. Your family welcomes you, sets the table — you bring them gifts. Then you visit friends, and walk along the familiar streets from your childhood, breathing in the scent of freshly fallen leaves. You drink tea or wine together and remember what it was like to be teenagers. Unfortunately, such a feeling is unknown to me. I left Vladikavkaz in 2020 and haven’t been home since. Meeting my loved ones has become a kind of quest — I can’t go

OC Insider

The OSCE’s tone-deaf visit to Azerbaijan

Last week, Elina Valtonen, the OSCE Chair-in-office and Finnish Foreign Minister, attended a demonstration in central Tbilisi as a show of support for the long-running protest movement against the Georgian Dream government’s anti-Western trajectory. While not the first EU diplomat to have attended a protest in Tbilisi, her attendance drove the government to say that it had cancelled her meeting with Prime Minister Irakli Kobakhidze — or so it seemed. Valtonen quickly hit back, saying that she

Most Popular

Editor‘s Picks