▲A voter casts his ballot in the second round of Georgia's municipal elections on 30 October. Photo: Mariam Nikuradze/OC Media.
Georgia’s opposition have refused to concede after preliminary results gave the ruling Georgian Dream party victory in all mayoral races except for the small constituency of Tsalenjikha.
‘Elections have been cancelled in this country’, Nika Melia, chair of the opposition UNM Party claimed in the early morning of 31 October while promising to come forward with an action plan in response to the preliminary results.
As polling stations closed at 20:00 on Saturday, both the ruling party and opposition groups celebrated victory based on conflicting exit polls by Gorbi, commissioned by pro-government TV channel Imedi, and by Anova for pro-opposition TV channel Mtavari.
In their tenth year of rule, the results suggest that Georgian Dream secured victory in 19 out of 20 cities and municipalities up for grabs in Saturday’s second round. Georgian Dream will add these victories to the 44 municipalities the party won outright in the first round on 2 October.
With all ballots counted, Giorgi Kharchilava from the United National Movement (UNM) narrowly defeated Georgian Dream candidate Goga Golordava in Tsalenjikha Municipality with 51% of the vote, making him the only opposition mayor in the country. The municipality in the western Samegrelo Region borders Abkhazia’s Gali District.
Giorgi Kharchilava is set to become the only mayor in the country not from the ruling party.
Georgian Dream also lost their majority on Tsalenjikha’s municipal council, where 16 out of 27 councillors will be from opposition groups.
A UNM-dominated coalition of opposition parties that included Girchi — More Freedom, Lelo, and Droa, failed to win the mayoral races in all five self-governing cities: Batumi, Kutaisi, Poti, Rustavi, and the capital Tbilisi.
The city of Rustavi is set to have a woman mayor, Nino Latsabidze, for the first time.
The narrowest margin was in Batumi, where Georgian Dream’s Archil Chikovani won 51% defeating the UNM’s Giorgi Kirtadze.
In Tbilisi, the incumbent mayor, Kakha Kaladze, was reelected with 56% of votes against UNM chair Nika Melia’s 44%.
Melia had named the leaders of Girchi, Lelo, and Droa as his would-be deputies in an attempt to persuade those on fence to vote for a ‘pluralistic’ alternative to Kaladze’s City Hall.
Kakha Kaladze adressing supporters outside the Georgian Dream HQ after polls closed. Photo: Mariam Nikuradze/OC Media.
In the hotly contested mayoral race in Zugdidi Municipality, Georgian Dream’s Giorgi Tsotseria won 52% of the vote, defeating Anzor Melia, Nika Melia’s father.
The municipal elections were the first in which Georgian Dream founder Bidzina Ivanishvili remained tight-lipped, and did not publicly campaign for the party he founded 10 years ago.
The municipal elections also saw the electoral debut of the For Georgia Party, founded by former Ivanishvili ally and former PM Giorgi Gakharia, who won 8% of the proportional vote in the first round. Gakharia attempted to distance himself and his party from the UNM throughout the campaign.
In the second round, his party was competing for 11 majoritarian council seats and one mayoral runoff race. The party is set to win six out of those majoritarian seats, all in Western Georgia.
Giorgi Gakharia served in several roles in the Georgian Dream Government from 2013, including as Prime Minister from September 2019–February 2021. Photo: Mariam Nikuradze/OC Media.
The voter turnout in the second round was 49%, 3 points less than in the first round.
Voter pressure, attacks on observers and journalists
The 30 October vote was marred with repeated reports of violations, including attacks on journalists.
‘During the second part of the voting day, an intensified tension hindered the voting process in several polling stations’, the Georgian Young Lawyers’ Association reported as polls closed.
The International Society for Fair Elections And Democracy (ISFED), a Georgian election watchdog, reported that their observers were interfered with in multiple locations throughout Georgia.
The Georgian Young Lawyers’ Association said Ivanishvili’s bodyguards had broken electoral rules by entering the polling station with him and obstructing journalists. Photo: Mariam Nikuradze/OC Media.
Beyond procedural violations, ISFED also reported two possible cases of vote-buying at two precincts in the Black Sea coast city of Batumi.
Commenting on the vote, US Ambassador to Georgia Kelly Degnan also claimed that embassy observers had reported attacks on journalists and observers.
The Ministry of Internal Affairs has launched investigations into at least nine incidents, including four against journalists, and one person has been arrested.
One of the most serious incidents took place in Zugdidi, where five people involved in a fight were briefly detained by police. According to local media, the conflict took place between Zugdidi majoritarian MP Irakli Chikovani from Georgian Dream and observers from Giorgi Gakharia’s For Georgia Party.
Police also launched an investigation into alleged death threats made against a municipal candidate from the UNM.
Police across the country also launched investigations into claims of party activists keeping lists of voters, physically or verbally abusing election observers, and gathering closer to polling station than is allowed.
One of the last reported violations occured when Nika Melia was attacked by an unknown man in Vazisubani District in Tbilisi.
Melia had arrived to the polling station after reports that there was a power cut in the polling station. The Interior Ministry is investigating the attack.
After fleeing a not-so-promising academic career and a disastrous attempt at being a bisexual activist, Shota is now a grumpy staff writer covering Georgia-related topics at OC Media. He focuses on nationalism, far-right movements, gender, and queer issues, with an eye on Eastern and Central Europe.
The holding of free and fair elections is central to democracy, yet, if elections are not considered free and fair, then polarisation and questions about their legitimacy can divide society. Polling from CRRC Georgia suggests a deep partisan divide in Georgia when it comes to views on the quality of elections in the country.
Data CRRC Georgia collected before the 2021 municipal elections for ISFED and after the elections for NDI shows that supporters of the ruling party and opposition were and
Georgian Dream have won a byelection for the Batumi City Council. While the council is now formally hung, a ‘neutral’ candidate is suspected to be a ruling party ally.
Georgian Dream’s candidate Ramaz Jincharadze won a convincing victory in Saturday’s vote for a majoritarian council seat in Batumi, Georgia’s second-largest city and the capital of the Autonomous Republic of Adjara.
The result will upset plans by opposition groups the United National Movement (UNM) and Lelo to deny the ruling
The opposition appears to have lost their majority on the Batumi City Council after the death of a councillor, allegedly following pressure from the government.
Nugzar Putkaradze died last Thursday in what his sister, who also sits on the city council, has said was a diabetic attack. The opposition United National Movement (UNM) have claimed that his blood sugar levels skyrocketed leading to his death after repeated attempts by people connected to the ruling party to make him defect.
Putkara
International and local election observers often note violations of the secrecy of the ballot in Georgia, and the 2021 local elections were no exception. According to a recent study, a plurality of people think such violations could take place in Georgia, and some have heard of such cases in the past year.
On the survey on election-related attitudes carried out by CRRC Georgia for ISFED, respondents were asked about a hypothetical country where a citizen’s vote was somehow revealed to a neig
